Something Witchy: A Sabrina the Teenage Witch Rewatch

It’s the Sabrina the Teenage Witch Season 1 finale, and we’re diving into Troll Bride! When Sabrina accidentally agrees to marry a troll, only a prince (aka Harvey) can save her—but first, Laura and Skye somehow end up talking a lot about sports. Plus, it’s a special edition of Sword Facts With Skye, where we discuss the sword fight that determines Sabrina’s fate. Join us as we say goodbye to Jenny, Mr. Pool, and the first season of Sabrina!

This week on Something Witchy, Laura and Skye revisit Sabrina the Teenage Witch Season 1, Episode 23, "The Crucible." When Sabrina’s class takes a historical trip to Salem, things take a turn for the dramatic as the students fully commit to reenacting the infamous witch trials—only to end up putting Sabrina and Jenny on trial! We break down the episode’s hilariously over-the-top Puritan experience, discuss Libby’s full Abigail Williams transformation, and wonder why Harvey plays every sport imaginable.

"Halibut, ho!" This week on Something Witchy, we dive into Sabrina the Teenage Witch Season 1, Episode 22 "The Great Mistake!" Skye and Laura take on magic salesmen, Tomorrow Balls, and the dangers of skipping mitochondria (the powerhouse of the cell!). We discuss whether Sabrina’s punishment was fair, why Mr. Pool was rocking a kilt, and the many career paths of Hilda and Zelda—including deep-sea fishing, coal mining, and showgirls in the Wild West?! Plus, we get to learn more about Salem's past!

Flu fever meets soap opera drama in this week’s episode of Something Witchy! Skye was battling a flu haze, so Laura took the reins as we dove into Sabrina the Teenage Witch Season 1 Episode 21 "As Westbridge Turns." We break down classic soap opera tropes, debate whether Sabrina and Harvey are finally official, and question the bizarre layout of Mr. Pool’s classroom. Plus, a PSA: get your flu shots, folks!

We finally get to learn more about Sabrina's family! Sabrina's dad comes to visit and brings along Gail...his girlfriend! Sabrina struggles to adjust to this while Laura struggles to discuss this episode without talking about her dating issues. But don't worry, there's plenty of discussion about weird food combinations, too! Join us as we watch Season 1 Episode 20 "Meeting Dad's Girlfriend."

This week, we're watching Season 1 Episode 19 "Cat Showdown." While Sabrina and Salem get into some hijinks at a cat show, we finally get to meet Dirk the Mailman and discuss inflation rates from 1997 to 2025. Will Sabrina finally be able to earn some money this season without taking a weird job from the school job board? Find out with us!

Sabrina gets jealous when Libby gets credit for making volunteering at a nursing home popular. Hilda and Salem try hair soup. Zelda has a new mystery man. Join Laura and Skye as they watch Season 1 Episode 18, "Sweet Charity" and talk way too much about hair in food. 

It's finally here! Sabrina and Harvey are going to have their first kiss! But of course magic causes everything to go awry. Skye and Laura talk about their own first kisses and magical genetics. Have you ever been turned into a frog by a witch kiss? You may be entitled to financial compensation. Join us as we discuss Season 1 Episode 17 "First Kiss."

Yet another TGIF teen romance is almost destroyed by a ski lodge on this week's episode. Chris Elliott guest stars and distracts Laura and Skye as they discuss the plot line they would have loved to see. Join us as we watch Season 1 Episode 16 "Mars Attracts!"

"I hope they play Hot To Go!" "This is a Violent Femmes episode." Hilda and Zelda relive their teen years when they accompany Sabrina and friends to meet the Violent Femmes. This episode prompted Skye and Laura to actually attend a Violent Femmes concert a few weeks later. Join us as we discuss Season 1 Episode 15 "Hilda and Zelda: The Teenage Years."